Is Healthy Revenue Hiding a Much Bigger Problem?
Posted by Katie Rogers on
New donor and member research points to a question worth asking alongside revenue and renewal totals: are people still choosing to stay connected?
6-minute read
Two reports released this fall look at very different groups: nonprofit donors and association members. But they raise the same uncomfortable question:
Can revenue look healthy while the relationship underneath it is getting weaker?
The Fundraising Effectiveness Project’s Q2 2026 report found that only 11.3% of donors acquired in 2025 had given again by the end of June 2026.
Put another way, almost nine out of ten new donors from last year had not yet returned to give during the first half of this year.
At the same time, dollars raised were up an estimated 6.6% year over year through Q2. That is good news. But when we look underneath that number, the picture becomes more complicated. Donor counts fell 1.6%, year-to-date retention through Q2 slipped to 26.4%, and Major and Supersize donors represented just 2.9% of donors while supplying 76.4% of dollars raised.
Revenue is growing while the donor base is shrinking and giving remains concentrated among a small share of supporters.
Association membership research raises a similar concern. Momentive Software’s 2026 membership research found that the share of members who were extremely likely to renew fell from 56% to 48%. The share giving the highest satisfaction rating dropped from 61% to 52%, with much of the decline among Millennial and mid-career members.
These studies look at different audiences and don’t tell us why those numbers changed. They do, however, lead us to the same practical question:
Are we looking closely enough at what happens between the first yes and the next one?
Retention starts before the next ask
Retention often becomes a major topic when the next appeal, renewal notice, or lapsed-donor campaign is being planned.
By then, the donor or member has already had months of experiences with the organization. They have been deciding all along whether the relationship feels worth continuing.
A donor notices whether the first gift was acknowledged correctly. They notice when a tribute recipient never receives a letter, when a recurring payment fails without a helpful follow-up, or when they have to explain the same issue to more than one person.
They also notice whether the organization tells them what their support helped accomplish and remembers what interested them in the first place.
A member notices whether welcome materials arrive, whether event registration recognizes their status, and whether a dues question is easy to resolve. They also notice whether the benefits, programs, and communications reflect where they are in their career and what they need now.
Inside an organization, these experiences may belong to different departments and work plans.
To the donor or member, they are all part of the same relationship.
People experience one organization
The database team may see a record problem. Finance may see a payment issue. The call center may receive the question. The lettershop or fulfillment team may be waiting for corrected information.
The person on the other end sees one organization.
They don’t know where a handoff broke. They know they had to call again, repeat the story, or wait longer than expected for something that mattered to them.
The same disconnect can happen in communications. Someone shares an interest, attends a program, or asks about a benefit, but that information never reaches the people planning the next interaction. The organization has learned something useful without using it.
That is why retention belongs in conversations across fundraising, membership, marketing, programs, and operations. Every team holds part of the picture.
The system matters. So does finishing the work.
A strong CRM or association management system gives an organization a shared record and better visibility. That is essential.
Still, the system cannot interpret every unusual gift, determine which duplicate record is correct, or know when a standard acknowledgement needs special handling. Having a field for someone’s interests also doesn’t mean those interests are informing what they receive.
Someone has to notice the issue, understand the organization’s rules, and own the outcome.
That last part matters. Moving a problem into another queue is different from knowing it was resolved. Recording a preference is only useful if it helps shape a future decision or interaction.
Technology helps teams see and coordinate the work. Experienced people give that information context and make sure it leads somewhere.
What should you measure alongside revenue?
Revenue and renewal reports absolutely matter. They should be paired with measures that show whether the relationship base is getting stronger or weaker.
For donor programs, I would want to see:
- Donor count alongside dollars raised
- First-to-second-gift conversion
- Retention by gift level and giving frequency
- Recurring-payment failures and recoveries
- Acknowledgement corrections and delays
- The questions donors repeatedly ask
- The reasons donors give when they stop or reduce their giving
For membership programs, I would look at:
- First-year renewal separately from overall renewal
- Satisfaction and renewal intent by career stage or member group
- Late renewals and unresolved payment issues
- Repeated questions and record corrections
- Use of the benefits members say they value
- The amount of manual work required to keep the experience moving
No single number will explain why someone stays or leaves. Together, these measures can help identify where to investigate, especially when reviewed alongside the programs, services, and communications people actually experienced.
Then do something with what you find
Start with one part of the relationship: a first gift, a member’s first year, or a group whose engagement is declining. Look at what those people experienced, what the organization offered them, and how it communicated along the way.
- Map the handoffs. What happens after the gift or renewal comes in? Who handles the record, payment, acknowledgement, question, and follow-up? Where does information get lost or someone have to ask twice?
- Pair the findings with what the organization is doing and communicating. Review the programs, events, benefits, impact updates, and other communications that group received. Did donors hear what their support helped accomplish? Did members learn about opportunities relevant to them? Look at timing, content, frequency, and channels alongside participation, giving, and renewal patterns.
- Use what you know about the people behind the numbers. Demographic coding, stated preferences, and engagement patterns can help explain differences within an audience. Some information comes directly from what people share. Other clues come from the content they respond to, events they attend, or benefits they use. Keep known information distinct from what you infer, and use both to ask better questions. Are mid-career members receiving communications that reflect their needs? Are donors with a particular interest hearing about the work they care about?
- Look for repeated friction and missed opportunities. Track delays, corrections, repeat contacts, and issues without a clear owner. Also look for relevant benefits that people aren’t using, updates they aren’t receiving, or interests that never make it into the next communication. A process can run correctly and still leave someone feeling overlooked.
- Assign someone to act on what you find. That might mean fixing a handoff, updating demographic or interest coding, changing a welcome sequence, or helping a program team communicate a benefit more clearly. Give the action an owner and a date to review it.
- Check whether the change helped. Look at whether the issue stopped recurring, whether people engaged with the revised communication or offering, and how giving or renewal develops over time. Use those findings to inform the next interaction.
Make the next interaction better informed
At Bungee, we see how much of the donor and member experience depends on connecting these pieces.
An acknowledgement needs to be accurate and reflect the gift someone chose to make. A conversation can resolve a question and reveal something useful about the person asking it. A record correction can help the next team recognize a supporter’s history instead of treating them as someone new.
Those details matter because people have already given the organization something: their money, their time, their interest, or their trust. What happens next tells them how thoughtfully that contribution was received.
Celebrate strong revenue and renewal results. Then ask whether more people are choosing to stay, whether the organization is learning from its interactions, and whether that knowledge is making the experience more relevant.
The next gift or renewal is being shaped right now, in the work happening between one interaction and the next.
Every interaction strengthens the next.
